I’ve Been a Doctor for 30 Years. Here’s Why I Don’t Care About “Your Truth”

Facts should not be superseded by feelings, to paraphrase a very famous podcaster.

Somewhere along the way, the English language got a software update nobody asked for. We used to have “the truth.” Now we have “my truth,” “your truth,” and “speaking my truth,” which is usually what someone says right before announcing that vitamin C cures everything from strep throat to a bad credit score.

I’m a pediatrician. I deal in facts every day. And I’m here to deliver some news gently, the way I deliver news about a double ear infection: there is no such thing as “your truth” when it comes to science. There’s the truth, and then there’s your opinion wearing the truth’s clothes and hoping nobody checks the ID.

Feelings Are Real. They’re Just Not Data.

Let me be fair. Your feelings matter. If you feel scared about your baby’s first shots, that fear is real, and I take it seriously. If you feel overwhelmed, anxious, or confused, I want to hear about it. Feelings are valid.

But feelings aren’t evidence. You can feel that gravity is a hoax. Go ahead and feel it hard. Then step off the roof and see whose truth wins. (Please don’t. That’s a hypothetical. My malpractice carrier has asked me to be clear about that).

Water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit at sea level whether you believe in it or not. Measles is wildly contagious whether you believe in it or not. Bacteria don’t check your Instagram bio before deciding whether to infect you. The universe isn’t taking feedback.

“But Science Changes Its Mind”

Yes, and that’s the best part. Science updates when better evidence comes along. That’s not “everyone has their own truth.” That’s the opposite. It’s a whole system built to catch mistakes, test ideas, and throw out the ones that don’t hold up.

When science changes, it’s because someone brought better data. When “my truth” changes, it’s usually because someone watched a new YouTube video at 1 a.m. Those aren’t the same thing. One is peer review. The other is a guy named Chad with a ring light.

Welcome to the Algorithm Buffet

I get it. It’s really hard to tell what’s true in 2026. Your phone is basically a personalized misinformation vending machine. You click on one video about “toxins” in baby food, and suddenly your feed is wall-to-wall with women in linen dresses whispering about seed oils over moody piano music.

That’s not an accident. Algorithms are designed to keep you scrolling, not to keep you informed. And outrage, fear, and surprise keep people scrolling better than boring old accuracy.

The research backs this up. A large MIT study published in Science looked at about 126,000 news stories shared on Twitter from 2006 to 2017 and found that false news spread farther, faster, deeper, and more broadly than the truth in every category of information. Falsehoods were 70% more likely to be retweeted than true stories, and it took true stories about six times as long to reach 1,500 people.

And here’s the kicker: it wasn’t the bots. The researchers found humans, not robots, were mainly responsible for spreading the false stuff, because false news felt more novel and people love sharing something new and shocking. So, the call is coming from inside the house. It’s us.

Confirmation Bias: Your Brain’s Hype Man

Add confirmation bias, and now we’ve got a real party. Confirmation bias is our natural tendency to seek out, believe, and remember information that supports what we already think, while ignoring anything that doesn’t.

It’s like having a hype man living in your head. You think vaccines are dangerous? Your hype man finds you 400 posts agreeing with you, and skips past the mountain of research from people who’ve actually studied it for decades. You think your toddler’s fever needs antibiotics? Your hype man reminds you of the one time your cousin’s kid got better after amoxicillin and conveniently forgets the 50 times kids got better on their own.

Everyone has confirmation bias. Me too. The difference is that doctors, scientists, lawyers, and accountants are trained to fight it by checking evidence, looking for what might prove them wrong, and following the data even when it’s inconvenient.

You’re Paying for the Expertise. Use It.

Here’s the part where I get a little cranky. You pay your pediatrician. You pay your attorney. You pay your accountant. And then, sometimes, you come in with a printout from a website called something like TruthWarriorMama.net and want to argue with the person you’re paying.

You wouldn’t hire an accountant and then tell them, “My truth is that I don’t owe taxes this year.” The IRS doesn’t do “my truth.” The IRS does audits.

You wouldn’t hire a defense attorney and then insist on representing yourself based on a TikTok about “sovereign citizen” loopholes. Well, some people do. You can watch those videos too. They do not end well.

So why do it with your child’s health? Your pediatrician went through years of medical school, residency, board exams, and continuing education, and has probably seen thousands of kids with the exact problem you’re worried about. That isn’t arrogance. It’s experience. It’s what you’re paying for. Get your money’s worth.

Ask Questions. Just Ask the Right People.

None of this means you should sit quietly and nod. Please ask questions. Push back. Ask, “How do you know that?” and “What does the evidence say?” A good doctor will happily explain. A good doctor will also say “I don’t know” when that’s the honest answer, and then go find out.

Just bring those questions to people who have training and accountability, not to the influencer whose expertise is selling supplements with a discount code.

The Bottom Line

Your feelings are real. Your opinions are yours. But the truth about science, medicine, the law, and your taxes doesn’t bend to how you feel about it. In an age of algorithms and outrage, the most rebellious thing you can do is trust actual expertise. Listen to your pediatrician, your attorney, and your accountant. You’re paying them for a reason, and it isn’t so you can ignore them.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for individualized medical advice. If you have questions about your child’s health, talk with your pediatrician.


Discover more from The Unfiltered Pediatrician

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share This Post: