I want to tell you the actual reason I started writing these posts, and it isn’t as noble-sounding as “patient education.” It’s this: it can take me ten minutes to explain why your kid doesn’t need an antibiotic for a virus, why your toddler doesn’t need a $400 supplement, or why the specialist who ordered five unnecessary tests was wrong to do it, and it takes the other guy fifteen seconds to just say yes and hand you what you came in for. Guess which option is more profitable, less confrontational, and dramatically easier on everyone’s Yelp review. I only get fifteen minutes with each family in my actual exam room, and I cannot personally out-argue every unnecessary prescription, every dubious supplement, and every overzealous referral one appointment at a time. But I can write it down once and reach more people than I ever could standing in one room, and if that means even a handful of families skip an unnecessary treatment, an unneeded procedure, or outright harm, then the time it takes to write this is worth it. Medicine has a scam problem, and the uncomfortable part isn’t that some bad actors are running it. It’s that most of the people running it took the same oath I did.
Doctors Took an Oath. Doctors Are Also People.
Here is the part nobody wants to say out loud at a hospital fundraiser: physicians are humans first and professionals second, and humans respond to incentives, social pressure, ego, and money whether or not they swore an oath about it. Researchers studying medical overtreatment have been blunt about this for years, pointing out that fee-for-service payment structures financially reward doctors and hospitals for doing more, not for doing what’s right, and that this incentive can quietly nudge physicians toward overstating the benefits of a test or procedure while downplaying its risks (Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research). This isn’t a hypothetical. In 2014, a Kentucky hospital agreed to pay the federal government $16.5 million to settle allegations that its cardiologists performed hundreds of medically unnecessary heart procedures, including coronary stents, pacemakers, and bypass surgeries, on patients who didn’t need them (Department of Justice), and MedStar Health separately paid $35 million to resolve allegations that one of its surgeons performed medically unnecessary stent surgeries while the hospital paid kickbacks for the referrals that fed the pipeline (JGL Law). Those aren’t rogue outliers operating outside the system. They’re extreme examples of an incentive structure that exists, in smaller and quieter forms, in exam rooms everywhere, every single day.
It Really Is Faster to Just Say Yes
I’m not going to pretend the honest path is even close to convenient. Studies on antibiotic prescribing for viral illnesses consistently find that physicians who believe a patient expects or wants an antibiotic are significantly more likely to prescribe one, even when they know it won’t help, because talking someone out of that expectation takes real time, and real time is the one resource a fifteen-minute appointment slot does not have (PMC). This is the mechanism behind an enormous amount of medical waste that has nothing to do with cartoonish villainy and everything to do with plain exhaustion. It is genuinely easier, in the moment, to write the script, order the scan, or nod along with what the other doctor already recommended than it is to sit down, explain the actual evidence, absorb the disappointed look on a patient’s face, and hold your ground anyway. Convincing someone to do the harder, correct thing is a slower, less satisfying transaction for everyone involved, including the doctor. That imbalance is exactly why bad incentives win as often as they do.
Greed Doesn’t Announce Itself. It Just Shows Up Wearing a Lab Coat
The most uncomfortable truth in all of this is that greed in medicine rarely looks like a mustache-twirling villain. It looks like a physician who happens to own a stake in the imaging center they keep referring patients to, ordering more scans than a colleague with no financial connection to the equipment would; research on physician self-referral consistently finds that referring physicians with an ownership interest order significantly more imaging than those without one (Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research). It looks like a specialist recommending the more lucrative procedure over the less profitable but equally effective one, and rationalizing it the whole way because their intentions still feel good to them. Doctors are not exempt from self-interest just because they wear a white coat and recite an oath in front of their families at graduation. We are exactly as capable of convincing ourselves we’re doing the right thing while doing the profitable thing as anyone else in any other profession. The oath doesn’t come with an immunity chip installed. It’s just a promise, and promises require actual daily effort to keep.
The Actual Advice
This is why I write these posts the long way, with citations, instead of just telling you what to do and moving on. I can’t sit across from every family who needs to hear this, but I can write it down once and let it travel further than my exam room ever could. Somebody has to make the case for the boring, unprofitable, occasionally disappointing truth, because the profitable lie is always going to be faster and easier to sell. Ask your doctor why. Ask what happens if you do nothing. Ask whether the test, the prescription, or the referral actually changes the outcome, or just changes the bill. Most of us are doing this for the right reasons. Some of us are doing it for reasons we’ve gotten very good at not examining too closely. You’re allowed to ask the question either way, and if this post saves even one family an unnecessary treatment, an unneeded procedure, or worse, then it did exactly what I started this website to do.
This article is for general educational purposes only and is not a substitute for individualized medical advice. Always consult your child’s own healthcare provider for recommendations tailored to your specific situation.
Sources:
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, “Medical Overtreatment”
JGL Law, “MedStar Health Settles False Claims Act Case For $35 Million”
PMC, “Managing Patient Pressure to Prescribe Antibiotics in the Clinic”