Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has opened investigations into alleged undisclosed financial incentives tied to childhood vaccine recommendations, including an August inquiry involving the American Academy of Pediatrics. The investigations are ongoing; an investigation is not a finding that pediatricians have done anything wrong.


Apparently, pediatricians are getting fabulous vaccine kickbacks.
Wonderful. Amazing. Thrilling.


Could someone please tell me where they are? Because I seem to have missed the envelope stuffed with Big Pharma cash somewhere between buying a $9000 vaccine refrigerator, paying a nurse to administer the vaccine, documenting the dose, filing the claim, ordering replacement stock, and answering the refrigerator alarm at 2:14 a.m. because the temperature drifted a fraction of a degree outside its approved range.

The AG might want to read my previous blog on the sunshine act, or why I can’t accept a Pollo Adobado taco from a pharma rep, who ran by Los Tacos No. 1, without signing a 3 page waiver.

Trust me, there are a lot better ways to make big money then going to college for 4 years then to medical school for 4 years. Then, spending 3 years in residency, and then becoming a pediatrician at age 30, with six figures of debt.


The Mythical Payday
The fantasy goes like this: pediatricians recommend vaccines because every tiny arm injected causes a pile of money to rain from the ceiling. The reality is less Ocean’s Eleven and more Office Manager’s Spreadsheet From Hell.
A vaccine in a pediatric office is not merely “a shot.” It is inventory that has to be purchased up front, stored correctly, monitored continuously, handled according to protocol, administered by trained staff, recorded in the chart and immunization registry, billed correctly, and replaced when reimbursement does not cover the actual cost of delivering it.


So yes, a medical practice may charge more than the wholesale purchase price of a vaccine. That is not a kickback. That is called running a business without closing the doors and turning the refrigerator into a very expensive beverage cooler.


The Nordstrom Test
Here is a concept that should not require a congressional hearing.
If Nordstrom buys a shirt from a manufacturer for $100, nobody expects Nordstrom to sell that shirt for $100. Nordstrom has to pay for the store, employees, insurance, utilities, security, advertising, inventory systems, and whatever fragrance is being sprayed near the handbags.


Medical offices work the same way—minus the tasteful lighting and a Prada display.
The cost of providing vaccination includes: The vaccine itself, purchased before the child ever arrives.
Needles, syringes, alcohol swabs, bandages, gloves, and medical-waste disposal. A purpose-built refrigerator or freezer, backup plans, temperature logs, and alarms. Staff time to administer, document, counsel, observe, bill, reconcile inventory, and chase down denied claims.


Electronic health records, state immunization-registry reporting, malpractice coverage, rent, utilities, health and dental insurance for my employees and payroll.

The delightful after-hours call when the refrigerator alarm goes off because it had the audacity to do its job. Calling all of that a “kickback” is like accusing Nordstrom of bribery because the shirt costs more after someone has paid the rent.


About That “Profit”
Pediatricians do not vaccinate children because we are plotting our retirement on a yacht made of Band-Aids. We recommend vaccines because preventing disease is preferable to explaining to terrified parents why their child is in the hospital with a preventable illness. I am old enough that I practiced before some of these vaccines were ever on the market. I have seen more than my fair share of young children die from meningitis, pneumonia and whooping cough. I hope to never again have to deliver news to a parent that their child is not going to survive the night, or they are going to leave the hospital, permanently disabled and all their future plans and dreams, for their child are gone.

The Texas AG’s January announcement said its inquiry would examine providers, insurers, manufacturers, and others for allegedly improper incentives; that is a broad allegation under investigation, not proof that routine pediatric vaccine recommendations are corrupt. If anyone has discovered the secret vaccine-money vault, please notify the rest of us. Preferably before we pay the next refrigerator repair invoice.


The Actual Priority
And for families without insurance—or with coverage that does not pay for vaccines—there is no secret pediatrician handshake followed by, “Sorry, kid, no cash, no protection.” We happily refer families to the local public-health department or vaccine-access program, where vaccines may be available free of charge or at a much lower government subsidized cost. The point is not where the vaccine is given. The point is that the child gets protected.


That is the alleged grand scheme:
A pediatrician wants your child less likely to suffer from a preventable disease. Truly sinister stuff.


Discover more from The Unfiltered Pediatrician

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share This Post: