Trust the Science, Why I Got the COVID Shot and Why I Want A Do-Over

Filed under: things I would like on the record before someone screenshots this out of context.

I got the COVID shot for the noblest reason of all, to keep doing what I love to do, taking care of children. Turns out “informed consent” gets a lot more informed when your employer is standing behind you holding a pink slip.

The real reason I rolled up my sleeve:

Let me shatter a few illusions right up front. I did not get the COVID vaccine because I was gripped by a stirring, patriotic urge to protect humanity. I did not get it because a glossy pharmaceutical commercial featuring a golden retriever and a soft piano melody convinced me that “together, we can.” I did not even get it because my Aunt Linda on Facebook, a woman who once tried to cure her sciatica with a magnet taped to a grapefruit, begged me to reconsider.

I got the COVID shot because my employer politely explained that if I didn’t, I could enjoy a lovely new career in something that was decidedly not pediatrics. Possibly greeting people at a big box store. Possibly explaining to my mortgage lender that my new passion was “freelance vibes.” That’s it. That’s the whole story. Roll credits.

Except, of course, there’s more. There’s always more when a pediatrician is involved, because we cannot let a single anecdote pass without turning it into a 1,200 word essay with footnotes.

A brief, sarcastic tour of my immune system:

Here is a fun fact I would like entered into the record: from roughly October 2019 through March 2020, before anyone in America had even heard the phrase “flatten the curve,” I and every one of my pediatric colleagues were breathing in the exhaled dreams of hundreds of small, sticky humans every single week. Children who coughed directly into my open mouth. Children who sneezed on my stethoscope with the enthusiasm of a fire hose. Children whose parents said, “Oh, he’s had a fever for four days, but I figured it was fine.”

We now know COVID was already quietly hitchhiking around the country during that window. Which means the pediatric workforce of America was, statistically speaking, being marinated in it before we even had a name for the marinade.

Then March 2020 arrived. We put on masks that fogged our glasses into legal blindness. Testing became a thing. And yet, plot twist, we kept getting exposed. Every. Single. Day. Because children, God bless them, are tiny plague vectors with backpacks. A four year old will remove her mask, if it interferes with showing you her loose tooth. A toddler will lick your badge. A school age kid will cough directly into the otoscope while you’re 5 inches from their face.

So by the time the vaccine rolled out, my immune system had, in all likelihood, already seen more spike protein than a Moderna scientist. My antibody titers were probably doing a little victory lap. My T-cells had built a small cabin in the woods and started writing their memoirs.

The antibody test that never was:

Here is where the sarcasm truly earns its keep. I asked, politely, professionally, with the demeanor of a woman who has memorized the pediatric immunization schedule for sport, if I could simply get an antibody test before the vaccine to document what my immune system had already accomplished on its own dime.

The answer was a resounding, institutional, HR approved: lol, no. Not “no, because antibody levels don’t correlate perfectly with protection.” Not “no, because titers alone are an imperfect proxy for immunity.” Those would have been reasonable, if debatable, answers. Those would have been an actual conversation. The answer was closer to: “We don’t care what your antibodies are doing. We don’t care if your plasma cells are throwing a parade. Get the shot or get out.”

Which is a fascinating stance, considering my entire medical education is built on the premise that we check titers for things all the time. If you adopted a baby from overseas with an unknown vaccination history, we would check their antibody titers to determine which vaccines they did need. In medical school I found out, through the humbling ritual of a titer draw, that my measles immunity had apparently wandered off somewhere between organic chemistry and my pediatrics rotation. My childhood MMR had packed a bag and left. So I was re-immunized against measles, because that is how we handle waning immunity: we measure it, and then we act on the measurement.

But COVID? Oh no. For COVID, measurement was heresy. Measurement was for cowards. Measurement was, apparently, a threat to the very fabric of occupational health. I could not shake the feeling that if I’d pushed too hard on “actually, I’d like a titer first,” someone in a windowless office would have pressed a red button labeled “Rogue Physician Detected.”

The very serious, very boring caveat:

Let me be extremely clear, in the same voice I use when a parent tells me their toddler ate a crayon: Would I do it again? No. Would I have gladly drawn a titer, documented immunity, and followed that science? Absolutely. Is natural immunity real? Yes, it is measurable, it is documentable, and for a pediatrician who spent two plus years soaking in respiratory droplets, it was almost certainly already there.

Is “we refuse to measure it and you must comply anyway” science? That’s not science. That’s a memo. My complaint is not with the concept of vaccines, I give them for a living and I believe in them. My complaint is with the vibe. The vibe being that asking a reasonable clinical question in 2021 was treated roughly the same as showing up to grand rounds in a clown wig. Half the country ignored the part of science that says measure before you intervene, and pretended that skipping the measurement was itself the scientific position.

What I would have loved to have see:

In a parallel universe where nuance was allowed to exist, my visit to employee health would have gone like this: Draw a tube of blood. Check my spike and nucleocapsid antibodies. Marvel, briefly, at the impressive titers of a pediatrician who has been sneezed on approximately 47,000 times. Have an actual, evidence informed conversation about the marginal benefit of vaccination on top of that. Instead I got: “Sleeve up, doc, and please stop asking questions like a person who went to medical school.”

The moral of the story:

I got vaccinated because I like being employed. I got vaccinated because my kids like eating food. I got vaccinated because the alternative was explaining to my patients’ parents that I was no longer their pediatrician due to a philosophical dispute about serology.

And you know what? I wouldn’t do it again. Not because I’ve gone rogue, and not because I’ve stopped believing in medicine, but because I am medicine, and medicine is supposed to measure things before it does things. Given a do-over, I’d walk into employee health, ask for the antibody panel I asked for the first time, and let the number on the page make the decision instead of the memo on the wall. That’s not anti-science. That’s the whole point of science.

The tragedy of the last few years isn’t that we had a vaccine, it’s that we had a lab, a needle, and a perfectly good tube of blood, and we were told to skip straight to the needle and never speak of the tube again. And that has contributed to the public mistrust of science.

So I saved my sarcasm for the blog. Which, if you’re reading this, is working out beautifully for both of us.

And of course, my opinions are my own. You do not have to agree, but I will respect the discourse on the topic.


Discover more from The Unfiltered Pediatrician

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share This Post: